RESULTS OF THE
2009 INTERCOLLEGIATE BUSINESS ETHICS CASE COMPETITION

Overall Winner: Emmons Award

Middle East Technical University, Ankara, Turkey (graduate): Duchess and Daughters: Their Secret Mission


Runners-up: Kerrigan Award

University of Arizona (undergraduate): Is the World Ready for the Nano? An Ethical Analysis of the Tata Nano

Montgomery College (undergraduate): An examination of Capital One's questionable tactics used to attract new customers and to generate additional revenues through the company's false fee, penalty, and service charge structure

United States Naval Academy (undergraduate): Decatur Securities


Divisional Winners

Graduate Division: (Tie)

Middle East Technical University, Ankara, Turkey
University of St. Thomas

Undergraduate Division 1: (Tie)

La Salle University
Villanova University

Undergraduate Division 2: (Tie)

Montgomery College
United States Naval Academy

Undergraduate Division 3:

University of Arizona


Ethics Short Form Winners/Runners-up

Division 1 Winner

University of Oregon (undergraduate): Economics and Ethics: Yahoo's Dilemma

Division 1 Runner-up

La Salle University (undergraduate): The ethical dilemmas present in the relationship between physicians and the pharmaceutical industry and their effect on the well being of the public

Division 2 Winner

Dartmouth College (graduate): Racism and Humor in the Workplace

Division 2 Runner-up

Villanova University (undergraduate): Responding to a Changing Landscape: Managerial Decisions and Consumer Protection

Division 3 Winner

Central European University Business School, Budapest, Hungary (graduate): To Freeze or not to Freeze: Assessment on energy distributors' responsibility for accessing energy to indigent customers through the example of a leading energy distributor, E.On

Division 3 Runner-up

Loyola Marymount University (undergraduate): Kraft’s South Beach Living Diet and Ending the Use of MSG


Ernst & Young 90 Second Challenge Winners

Clafin University (undergraduate): Insurance Card and Credit Score, Please!

Montgomery College (undergraduate):An examination of Capital One's questionable tactics used to attract new customers and to generate additional revenues through the company's false fee, penalty, and service charge structure

University of Illinois (undergraduate): Holocaust Victims Money being taken after the War


Meggitt Award for Best Ethical Analysis (Tie)

La Salle University (undergraduate): The ethical dilemmas present in the relationship between physicians and the pharmaceutical industry and their effect on the well being of the public

Middle East Technical University, Ankara, Turkey (graduate): Duchess and Daughters: Their Secret Mission


Carol Gilligan Ethics Essay Award

Middle East Technical University, Ankara, Turkey (graduate): Duchess and Daughters: Their Secret Mission


Carol & Stanley Botts Essay Award in Servant Leadership

California Polytechnic State University, San Luis Obispo (graduate): Monsanto's Indian Impact


10K Biathlon Winner

United States Military Academy at West Point (undergraduate)